Meeting of the Russian Association of International Law. Anniversary meeting of the Russian Association of International Law. Association membership
Information about the 55th Annual Meeting
Russian Association of International Law
On June 27-29, 2012, the Russian International Law Association held the 55th annual meeting on the topic "Actual problems of modern international law" in the Accounts Chamber of the Russian Federation.
The meeting was opened by the President of the Association Doctor of Law, Professor AND I. Kapustin.
The Chairman of the Accounts Chamber of the Russian Federation, Doctor of Law, Professor, addressed the participants of the meeting with a greeting S.V. Stepashin.
In his speech, he expressed gratitude to the Association for the fact that it regularly holds annual meetings in the premises of the Accounts Chamber of the Russian Federation.S.V. Stepashin noted the relevance of the issues that were included in the agenda of the meeting. In particular, in the modern world, the concept of "Responsibility to protect", the problems of the legal consequences of Russia's accession to the WTO, etc., are becoming increasingly important.
As part of the opening of the meeting, the Director of the Federal State Budgetary Institution of Science of the Institute of State and Law of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Academician of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Vice President of the Association A.G. Lisitsyn-Svetlanov, who drew attention to the fact that the Russian Academy of Sciences stood at the origins of the Association, instructing the Institute of Law of the USSR Academy of Sciences to provide all possible assistance to the Association in the implementation of its activities.
Thus, in particular, the Association was established by the Decree of the Presidium of the USSR Academy of Sciences No. 259 “On the establishment of the Soviet Association of International Law under the Department of Economic, Philosophical and Legal Sciences of the USSR Academy of Sciences” within the framework of the Institute of Law of the Academy of Sciences CCC R.
A.G. Lisitsyn-Svetlanov drew attention to the need for further research in the field of international space law, innovative development of the economy of Russia, the Arctic, the continental shelf, conflicts in the Middle East, legal issues of Russia's accession to the WTO, etc.
The Association has been successfully cooperating with the Institute of State and Law of the Russian Academy of Sciences throughout its 55 years of activity.
Then the floor for greetings was given to the Director of the Legal Department of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Russia K.G. Gevorgyan , who read out the greeting of the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Russia S.V. Lavrov members of the Association meeting. Greeting S.V. Lavrov was devoted to the need to form a modern world legal order based on the rule of law and the inviolability of the sovereignty of states.
UN Under-Secretary-General for Legal Affairs Patricia O'Brien noted in her speech that international law in Russia takes precedence over national law. At the same time, the application of international law occupies a central place in the activities of the United Nations. States must comply with international treaties and be held accountable for war crimes, genocide, human rights violations, and so on.
The head of the regional delegation of the International Committee of the Red Cross in the Russian Federation, Belarus, Moldova and Ukraine addressed the meeting participants with a greeting Juan Luis Coderque Galligo.
The meeting considered and discussed topical issues of modern international law, including the concept of responsibility of states and the world community for protecting the rights of citizens (responsibility to protect) in the context of internal conflicts, the current state of the institution of responsibility in international space law, modern problems of international maritime law in connection with 30th anniversary of the adoption of the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea, various aspects of international criminal and humanitarian law. Discussions were held on the international legal issues of the EurAsEC and the Customs Union, as well as WTO law in connection with Russia's accession to this international organization. In a specially adopted statement, the Association confirmed the compliance of the Russian Constitution with the provisions of the Protocol on our country's accession to the WTO Agreement. Within the framework of the meeting, a section on topical issues of private international law worked.
All participants of the annual meeting highly appreciated the scientific and organizational level of this event.
President of the Association A.Ya. Kapustin made a report on the activities of the Association and the prospects for its development, and also summed up the work of the 55th annual meeting.
More than 350 members of the Association attended the 55th annual meeting. More than 80 members of the Association and guests of the meeting made presentations and reports, as well as discussions at the 55th annual meeting.
international legal law association
International law is a system of legal principles and norms that regulate relations between peoples and states and determine their mutual rights and obligations. International law was formed regardless of the desire of a particular person or a particular social group or stratum, but as a result of objective social processes caused by the need to establish international communication. Even at the earliest stages of human development, primitive tribes maintained intertribal relations among themselves, which were regulated by customs and traditions. They became the prototype of international legal norms that appeared with the emergence of statehood among the peoples of the world.
The peculiarity of international law is that its norms are created as a result of an agreement between independent and equal subjects of international law - sovereign states. The norms of international law are contained in bilateral and multilateral interstate treaties, and are also formed in the form of international customs. International treaty and international custom are the main sources of international law.
International law arose even before the emergence of the state, since even at the communal level, people from different tribes had to cooperate with each other. In 1286 BC Between Pharaoh Ramesses II and the Hittite king, the first written peace treaty was concluded, carved on stone. This treaty formulated a provision that ensured its strict observance.
Thus, international law is a product of interaction in the process of cooperation and struggle of various states. International law is a special legal system. It differs from national systems, since in international relations there is no body that would enforce compliance with obligations. Everything is based on voluntariness. Pacta sunt servanda - contracts must be respected (still from Roman law).
A feature of international law is its conciliatory nature: international law is coordinating in nature, and national law is subordinate. Actors in the international arena themselves agree on the rules of their behavior. Another feature is the intergovernmental nature of relations regulated by international law, i.e. States and intergovernmental organizations are its subjects, actors.
The International Law Association has consultative status with the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) and a number of other organizations.
Organized in Brussels in 1873. It was originally called the Association for the Reform and Codification of the Law of Nations. Since 1895 it has been renamed the International Law Association.
There is also the Russian Association of International Law in Russia, it is the legal successor and successor of the Soviet Association of International Law (SAMP), established in 1957 on the initiative of leading Russian international lawyers. The main goals of the Association were to promote the unification of the scientific and intellectual potential of science and practice, the exchange of experience for the purpose of progressive development, updating and effective application of international public and private law.
Professor G.I. Tunkin, who combined the features of an experienced practitioner in the field of international law and an organizer of education.
L.V. was elected the first Scientific Secretary of the Association. Korbut, who holds this position to the present day.
The Association lived, grew, matured, uniting in its ranks teachers, practitioners, research scientists, as well as students and graduate students interested in international law.
Today the Association unites all persons interested in the problems of modern international law, living and working in the Russian Federation. Its doors are open to representatives of the scientific community, teachers, graduate students and students, as well as practitioners from the CIS countries and any other states that are interested in its activities.
The Association promotes publishing activities, under its auspices the Russian Yearbook of International Law and several journals on international law are published.
The Association actively participates in the events held by the World Association of International Law, information about the activities of which will be constantly posted on the website of our Association.
The Association actively cooperates with the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Russia, other state and public organizations of our country.
Russian Association of International Law
Review of the 57th Annual Meeting of the Russian Association of International Law (June 25–27, 2014)
The analytical review considers reports and speeches made at the 57th Annual Meeting of the Russian Association of International Law on June 25-27, 2014.
Korbut L. V. REVIEW OF THE 57TH ANNUAL MEETING OF THE RUSSIAN INTERNATIONAL LAW ASSOCIATION (JUNE 25-27, 2014)
The Review focuses on researching reports and presentations made at the 57th Annual Meeting of the Russian Association of International Law on June 25-27, 2014.
On June 25, the Meeting was opened by Doctor of Law, Professor, President of the Association A. Ya. Kapustin. In his speech, he expressed gratitude to S.Yu. Gaverdovskaya.
L. A. Gaverdovskaya greeted the participants of the Meeting on behalf of the management and judiciary of the Moscow Arbitration Court and wished fruitful work, interesting discussions, solving the tasks and new scientific research that contribute to the development of international law and its effective application.
Then Ambassador Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary, Director of the Legal Department of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Russia K. G. Gevorgyan addressed the participants of the meeting with a greeting, who read out the greeting of the Minister of Foreign Affairs S. V. Lavrov.
Academician of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Director of the Institute of State and Law of the Russian Academy of Sciences A. G. Lisitsyn-Svetlanov wished successful work to all participants of the Meeting, both on his own behalf and on behalf of the Institute of State and Law of the Russian Academy of Sciences, as well as from the Department of Social Sciences of the Russian academy of sciences.
Doctor of Law, Professor, Deputy of the State Duma of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation V. N. Likhachev conveyed the official words of greeting on behalf of the State Duma of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation. He noted that the past year was full of the search for concepts and mechanisms for the most effective application of international law.
Head of Staff of the Association of Russian Lawyers S.V. Alexandrov conveyed the words of greeting from the co-chairman of the Association of Russian Lawyers Doctor of Law, Professor S.V. Stepashin, who for many years hosted the annual meetings of the Association within the walls of the Accounts Associations are excellent events for the transfer of knowledge and experience from older generations to younger generations of international lawyers.
Then he read out a greeting from the Chairman of the Association of Lawyers of Russia, Chairman of the Committee of the State Duma of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation on Civil, Criminal, Arbitration and Procedural Legislation, Honored Lawyer of the Russian Federation, Doctor of Law, Professor P. V. Krasheninnikov.
Deputy Minister of Justice of the Russian Federation M. A. Travnikov, on his own behalf and on behalf of the Minister of Justice of the Russian Federation A. V. Konovalov, expressed gratitude for the opportunity to take part in the 57th Annual Meeting of the Association and expressed his wish to strengthen the interaction of the Russian Association of International Law with the Ministry of Justice of the Russian Federation, both within the framework of the scientific advisory council and within the framework of activities under the auspices of the Ministry of Justice of the Russian Federation.
Bruno Uskin, Deputy Head of the Regional Delegation of the International Committee of the Red Cross in the Russian Federation, Belarus and Moldova, delivered a welcoming speech.
Then Doctor of Law, Professor, Deputy Chairman of the Court of the Eurasian Economic Community T.N. Neshatayeva considered some issues of the Treaty on the Eurasian Economic Union, signed in Astana on May 29, 2014.
After that, a plenary session "Generally recognized principles and norms of international law in the context of globalization" was held under the guidance of Doctor of Law, Professor E. G. Lyakhov.
Doctor of Law, Professor O. I. Tiunov made a presentation “The principle of sovereign equality of states in the system of norms of modern international law”.
He noted that recently there has been an opinion that in connection with the creation of numerous integration systems, states are losing part of their sovereignty. However, one cannot agree with the point of view that the transfer of any powers by the states to an integration entity means the loss of part of their sovereignty.
Doctor of Law, Professor S. V. Chernichenko made a presentation on "Imperative Norms and Generally Recognized Principles of International Law".
The speaker noted that the concept of "imperative norms" does not appear in the Constitution of the Russian Federation. However, this does not mean that the concept of "imperative norms" is absent in the Russian legal system.
Doctor of Law, Professor L. N. Galenskaya made a presentation “International Arbitration: History and Development Trends”.
The speaker noted that for a long time arbitration developed in parallel with mediation.
At the end of the XIX century. with the creation of the arbitral tribunal, a permanent arbitration body appears, which is sometimes called the Permanent Court of Arbitration.
Currently, the process of nationalization of arbitration as an institution for resolving disputes is underway. Arbitration tribunals become dependent on states that specify how arbitration should proceed.
Doctor of Law, Professor V. A. Kartashkin made a presentation "Reforming the human rights mechanisms of the United Nations in the context of globalization."
The speaker noted that the activities of the United Nations General Assembly have changed over the past decades. The United Nations General Assembly adopts normative resolutions that come into force only after they have been ratified by States.
Doctor of Law, Professor A. A. Moiseev made a presentation "Globalization and International Law". He noted that, by its very nature, international law is global law. The term "globalization" appeared in the 1990s. The emergence of globalization was associated with the perception of the rules of a market economy by all states of the world, as well as the emergence of the Internet in 1991 as a public network.
At present, globalization is objective. Of greatest interest is the economic component of globalization. The advantages of globalization are associated with ensuring the stability of the economies of states. The disadvantages of globalization are related to the fact that the only purpose of globalization in the economic sphere is to make a profit, which negatively affects the social sphere and security.
Doctor of Law, Professor O. I. Ivonina made a presentation "The problem of the international legal personality of the state in the new world order."
She noted that the concept of a new world order appeared as a response to the objective processes of globalization and became widespread in the Western science of international law.
Head of the Department of International Law, Lomonosov Moscow State University M. V. Lomonosov Ph.D. in Law, Associate Professor A. S. Ispolinov made a presentation “The Constitutional Courts of the countries of the Eurasian Economic Union and the Eurasian legal order”.
He drew attention to the fact that the formation of the Eurasian legal order is currently taking place. More than 90 international treaties have been concluded, more than 750 decisions of the Eurasian Economic Commission have been adopted, there are numerous decisions of the Court of the Eurasian Economic Union.
The constitutional courts of the countries of the Customs Union met the new legal order with great caution, since norms appear in national law, the constitutionality of which the constitutional courts do not control.
Candidate of Legal Sciences, Associate Professor A. M. Barnashov made a report "On international treaties of constitutional and legal significance."
The speaker noted that in the system of international legal regulation, international treaties with constitutional and legal content, which have a significant impact on the development of various branches of law, are of particular importance. In a number of cases, international treaties require adjustments to the text of the constitution, and even its revision.
Candidate of Legal Sciences, Professor N. I. Malysheva made a presentation "On the theoretical origins of understanding the rule of law in international law."
She noted that legality could be seen as an idea, a principle or a legal regime. In modern international law, legality presupposes compliance with imperative norms, the provisions of the Charter of the United Nations.
Candidate of Legal Sciences, Associate Professor R. Sh. Davletgildeev made a presentation "The influence of civilizational features on the functioning of international labor law."
In the modern world, along with globalization, there are also processes of regionalization. In this regard, some features of international labor law are being formed.
Among the civilizational features of international labor law, one can note the features of labor rights, migration features, etc.
Then a plenary session "Actual problems of international law in the context of globalization" was held under the guidance of Doctor of Law, Professor O. I. Tiunov.
Candidate of Law, Associate Professor N. V. Afonichkina made a report “Legal conditions for the exercise by the people of the right to self-determination in the light of the international legal principle of equality and self-determination of peoples and nations”.
She drew attention to the fact that one of the urgent problems of modern international law is the problem of self-determination of peoples. The principle of equality and self-determination of peoples was enshrined in Part 2 of Art. 1 of the Charter of the United Nations and detailed in many international legal instruments.
Professor B. M. Ashavsky made a presentation “The Doctrine of International Law at the Present Stage”. He noted that in the early stages of the development of international law, there were a small number of international treaties, and in this regard, the doctrine was one of the main sources of international law.
In the doctrine of international law at the present stage, many concepts are not used quite correctly. For example, the term "legality" refers to the internal law of States and therefore the concept of "international legality" is inappropriate in international law. The term "soft law", which refers to a set of resolutions of a recommendatory nature, should also not be used in international law.
Doctor of Law, Professor E. G. Lyakhov made a report "The subjects of ensuring the security of the world community." The speaker noted that at present the security threats to the world community are quite real.
In this regard, he considered the following issues: the concept and main components of security; the state as a political and legal mechanism and an object of security; the concept of the world community; modern threats to the security of the state and the world community; political and legal foundations for ensuring the security of states; international legal support for the preservation and protection of the world community, etc.
Candidate of Legal Sciences N. M. Bevelikova made a presentation “International Legal Problems of Integration in Asia in the Context of Globalization”. The speaker noted that the BRICS countries - Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa - are playing an increasingly important role in the system of international relations. In this regard, she considered some aspects of the status and activities of the BRICS.
PhD in Law, Associate Professor A. R. Kayumova made a presentation “Jurisdictional Grounds for Initiating Criminal Cases on the Situation in Ukraine: Principles of Universality and Protection”.
The speaker discussed some of the legal grounds for the criminal cases initiated by the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation in connection with the situation in Ukraine.
Candidate of Legal Sciences, Candidate of Political Sciences, Associate Professor K. L. Sazonova in the report “The Law of International Responsibility: Searching for Answers to the Questions “Who is to Blame?” and "what to do?" noted that the topic of the law of international responsibility was complex and very broad.
The most important problems of the law of international responsibility include the following: the obsolescence of the doctrine of the law of international responsibility in connection with the emergence of new concepts, such as the concept of humanitarian intervention; disorder of norms and concepts of the law of international responsibility; problems of implementation of the law of international responsibility; insufficient development of responsibility for serious violations of obligations arising from peremptory norms of general international law, etc.
Professor W. Butler made a presentation on the topic "Freedom of the Seas and Gerard de Reyneval". He noted that the 1811 study of the high-ranking French diplomat Gerard de Reyneval on the freedom of the seas touched on issues directly related to the Anglo-American conflict. Among others, this work explored the problems of claiming maritime territories, freedom of the sea, etc.
Candidate of Law, Associate Professor Kuan Zengjun made a presentation on "Delimitation of maritime spaces between China and its neighboring states."
The speaker noted that China is a continental maritime power. The total length of China's sea coastline is 17,000 kilometers. China borders on the sea with eight states. In this regard, China has always paid special attention to the delimitation of maritime spaces between China and its neighboring states.
Doctor of Law, Professor G. M. Melkov made a presentation “On insufficient coverage of the problems of military navigation in the Russian science of international law”. The speaker noted that in the scientific literature on international law, insufficient attention was paid to the legal status of warships.
Then a round table was held jointly with the European Association of International Law "International legal problems of activities in the polar regions" under the leadership of Doctor of Law, Professor A. N. Vylegzhanin and Vice-President of the European Association of International Law A. Nolkemper.
Professor Timo Koivurova made a presentation "Protection of the Arctic environment - approaches to the strategy of environmental protection in the Arctic and the Arctic Council". The speaker noted that joint efforts of the Arctic states are needed to protect the Arctic environment.
Professor Nele Matz-Luk, in her presentation “Marine Living Resources”, drew attention to the fact that the issue of marine living resources is very acute in the Arctic region. At the same time, new international legal agreements are needed to regulate the issues of marine living resources.
Doctor of Law V. S. Kotlyar in his report “Political and international legal advantages and problems that may arise for the Russian Federation in connection with the intensification of the operation of the Northern Sea Route” drew attention to the fact that at present the international community has become much more actively use the Northern Sea Route.
Doctor of Law, Professor Yu. N. Maleev made a presentation “On the Law of Environmental Protection in the Arctic Region”. The speaker noted that the situation in the oil and gas sector in the Arctic region is very difficult.
At the same time, by the time Russia has created all the necessary infrastructure, oil and gas reserves in the Arctic will have already been depleted. In this regard, the question of whether Russia should participate in the development of Arctic resources remains open.
Doctor of Law, Professor V.F. Tsarev in his report “General Description of the International Legal Status of the Arctic” noted that recently there have been publications on the legal aspects of the status of the Arctic, based on the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea 1982.
Professor Lauri Malksoo in his report “Russian Legal Claims in the Arctic” drew attention to the fact that the main issue in the field of Russian legal claims in the Arctic is the distribution of natural resources.
In the field of Russia's legal claims in the Arctic, there are a lot of problems that are still waiting to be resolved. However, the speaker expressed the hope that the states, as a result of the negotiations, would be able to reach a compromise solution.
A. Babina made a presentation "The rights of the inhabitants of the Arctic." She noted that fishing is the primary source of livelihood for the inhabitants of the Arctic. In this regard, in order to protect the rights of the inhabitants of the Arctic, joint efforts of states are needed to preserve its living resources.
On June 26, the section of private international law “Modern trends in the development of private international law. The role of international organizations” under the guidance of Professor S. N. Lebedev.
Professor E. V. Kabatova in her report “Modern trends in the development of private international law” considered the most relevant novels in Section VI of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation “Private International Law”.
Doctor of Law N. A. Shebanova made a presentation on the new topic "Judicial protection of intellectual property rights in the fashion industry."
At the beginning of her speech, the speaker drew attention to the fact that the legal support of the fashion industry is a new specialization of lawyers dealing with the protection of rights to objects of intellectual activity. Articles, comments, monographs on the problems of protecting the rights of persons employed in the fashion industry that have appeared in the press indicate that a new direction, called "fashion law" - "fashion law", is being formed into an independent legal discipline, characterized by a comprehensive approach to considering legal support for the functioning of the fashion industry and ways to protect the rights of persons employed in this industry.
The main emphasis in the speech was made on the fact that the specificity of intellectual property objects in the fashion industry dictates the need to resort to various methods of protection. The popularity of a peaceful way of resolving a dispute, and it is used quite often when “fashionable” conflicts arise, is largely due to the timing: the seasonal nature of fashion, its variability dictates the need to find a compromise as soon as possible, otherwise the copyright holder simply loses interest: the object of the dispute goes out of fashion and costs to protect it become economically unprofitable.
The report emphasized that the emerging jurisprudence on the protection of rights to fashion objects indicates certain difficulties in dealing with this category of disputes. This is due to the specifics of the formulation and description of intellectual property objects, the need to distinguish between the utilitarian and aesthetic components of the disputed object.
Russian jurisprudence has not gone unnoticed either. The report analyzes one of the interesting cases considered by the Intellectual Property Rights Court - a dispute between Rospatent and Lacoste on the registration of the designation "L.12.12" as a trademark.
Doctor of Law, Professor G. V. Petrova made a presentation on "International Private Law Regulation of Financial Markets".
The speaker drew attention to the fact that the issue of international private law regulation of financial markets has become increasingly important in connection with Russia's accession to the World Trade Organization.
Candidate of Law, Associate Professor E. V. Vershinina in her report “Conflict-of-law regulation of marriage in Russia and abroad (application of the Hague Conventions on separation and divorce)” noted that recently there has been a change in the conflict-of-law regulation of marriage in Russia.
A. V. Grebelsky made a report "Actual problems of application of the 1970 Hague Convention on the taking of evidence abroad in civil and commercial cases."
The speaker noted that under the 1970 Convention on the Taking of Evidence Abroad in Civil or Commercial Matters, the judicial authorities of some contracting states may directly request the authorized bodies of other states to provide evidence, execute letters of request. However, Russian courts do not fully use the Convention on the Taking of Evidence Abroad.
Professor O. N. Zimenkova made a presentation “Conflict regulation of obligations arising from unfair competition and restriction of competition”.
She noted that, as a general rule, obligations arising from unfair competition are reduced to minimizing damage to one or more competitors in the market.
According to Art. 1222 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation, obligations arising from unfair competition are subject to the law of the country whose market is affected or may be affected by such competition.
Teacher A.E. Kolchenkova in her report “The Hague Convention on the Law Applicable to Road Accidents” noted that in the Russian Federation the number of road accidents involving citizens of other states is increasing.
Associate Professor E. I. Kaminskaya made a presentation “Types of damages in contractual and tort (including copyright) relations”. She noted that in 1992, in Russian legislation, in relation to programs of electronic computers, and then to other objects of copyright, such a method of protection as compensation appeared.
Postgraduate student P. E. Ivlieva in her report “Rebuttable and Invalid Arbitration Awards: Peculiarities in Swedish Law” noted that at present international arbitration is a very popular way of resolving disputes.
As a rule, state courts limit themselves to considering only the procedural aspects of arbitration proceedings and verifying that the principles of fairness and legality are observed.
- V. Guskov in his speech “Legal Mechanisms for Combating Abuse of Interstate Agreements on the Avoidance of Double Taxation” noted that at present agreements on the avoidance of double taxation are largely outdated.
Post-graduate student S. V. Usoskin in his report “Peculiarities of international legal protection of cross-border investments and investments in derivatives” considered topical issues of investment arbitration.
In the past, cross-border investments were defined as property values invested in the territories of foreign states.
Subsequently, in the context of globalization, new types of investments began to appear. In this regard, most states have concluded many bilateral investment protection agreements that provide a number of investor guarantees, such as receiving compensation in case of expropriation, the right to apply to arbitration, etc.
- A. Nikitina in her report "On some questions of inheritance in private international law" considered some aspects of inheritance relations in private international law.
The complexity of inheritance issues lies in the need to unify them. Each state has its own traditions and its own legislation, which prevents its unification at the international level.
Candidate of Legal Sciences, Associate Professor I. A. Orlova made a presentation “Differentiation of Jurisdictions as a Consequence of the Development of Transnational Law”.
She noted that currently in the legal system there are a number of independent systems of national law, international law, European Union law. All these systems of law are self-sufficient, which is confirmed by the established mechanisms for resolving disputes. In this regard, litigation may be resolved under national law, international law or European Union law.
Then the section "Actual Issues of International Law in Regional Economic Integration" was held under the guidance of Doctor of Law, Professor A. A. Moiseev.
Doctor of Law, Professor E. G. Moiseev made a presentation "International legal foundations for the creation and operation of the Eurasian Economic Union."
The speaker noted that the Treaty on the Eurasian Economic Union dated May 29, 2014 sets out the main parameters of economic cooperation between states.
Doctor of Law, Professor M.S. Bashimov in his report “Problems of Eurasian Integration: Kazakhstan's View” noted that the conclusion of the Treaty on the Eurasian Economic Union was preceded by certain difficulties. Thus, the Republic of Kazakhstan and the Republic of Belarus did not fully agree to share competence and transfer part of their sovereign powers to supranational bodies.
Doctor of Law, Professor L. I. Volova in her report “The Law of Regional Economic Integration” noted that international integration is of great value.
In connection with the signing of the Treaty on the Eurasian Economic Union, it becomes necessary to develop the law of international economic integration as a sub-branch of international economic law.
Candidate of Legal Sciences, Associate Professor N. M. Sidorenko made a presentation “Goals and “acquis” of the European Union in the light of the Lisbon Treaty”.
The speaker noted that the term “acquis” can be defined as a complex, interdisciplinary concept of a universal nature, which is increasingly being used in sociological, historical, cultural contexts.
There is now an extensive literature on various aspects of the uniform use of the basic acquis elements. However, the notion of a "basic acquis" remains debatable and requires further research.
Candidate of Law, Associate Professor D.S. Boklan in her report “Natural resources as an object of international environmental and international economic relations” drew attention to the fact that natural resources can be included in the structure of the subject of both international economic law and international environmental law.
Candidate of Legal Sciences O. V. Kadysheva made a presentation “Application of the provisions of the World Trade Organization agreements by Russian courts”.
The speaker recalled that the application of the provisions of the World Trade Organization agreements by Russian courts is carried out in accordance with paragraph 4 of Art. 15 of the Constitution of the Russian Federation.
However, the agreements of the World Trade Organization cannot be automatically integrated into the Russian legal system, since their application requires the improvement of national law.
This directly follows from paragraph 4 of Art. 16 of the Marrakesh Agreement establishing the World Trade Organization in 1994 2 , according to which member states are obliged to bring domestic legislation in line with their obligations arising from membership in the World Trade Organization.
Teacher E. A. Vladimirova made a presentation “Possibilities of using the experience of European integration in building the customs union of Russia, Kazakhstan, Belarus”.
She noted that borrowing the experience of European integration in building the customs union of Russia, Kazakhstan, Belarus can be carried out in the following main areas: conceptual apparatus; direct, immediate and priority action of the rules of law; powers to hold accountable, etc.
E. V. Mashkova in her speech “The procedure for resolving interstate disputes within the framework of the free trade area “The European Free Trade Association” (EFTA) considered some topical issues of the activities of the European Free Trade Association.
Candidate of Law S. V. Glandin in his report “Deoffshorization of the Russian Economy and International Law” noted that 9 out of 10 transactions concluded by large Russian companies are not regulated by Russian law.
In this regard, the deoffshorization of the Russian economy can be defined as a system of government measures aimed at a significant reduction in foreign offshore structures in Russian civil circulation.
Candidate of Law G. A. Korolev in his report “The Role of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development in the Formation of the Global Financial Architecture and the Development of the Financial Markets of States” drew attention to the fact that the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development was established in 1961. Russia did not join Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, but may nevertheless participate in its work.
Cooperation with the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development can contribute to the application of best practices for the development of Russian financial markets.
Candidate of Law, Associate Professor N. A. Chernyadyeva in the report “The Conventional Model of International Terrorism as a Criminal Act” considered some universal anti-terrorist acts adopted in the United Nations system.
International terrorism is one of the consequences of globalization. Currently, there are 16 United Nations agreements in the field of combating international terrorism, in which more than 170 states participate.
Then the section "Actual problems of the theory and practice of international law" was held under the guidance of Doctor of Law V. S. Kotlyar.
Associate Professor E. I. Maksimenko in her report “Interests of the state and the international community and their relationship in the international legal system” noted that modern international law is a model of a normal human community.
The interests of the international community are as follows: peace, security, general and complete disarmament, preservation of resources for future generations. At the same time, the interests of states are not fully reflected in the norms of international law.
In this regard, there are contradictions between the interests of states and the international community. If these contradictions are not eliminated, then conflicts of various levels may arise. Compliance with the principles and norms of international law will allow solving many global problems of our time.
Candidate of Legal Sciences A. V. Iglin in his report “The Role of Globalization in the Development of International and European Sports Law” drew attention to the fact that in the modern world sports legal relations are becoming global. Currently, globalization has a noticeable impact on legal acts and sporting events in various states.
A. M. Pochuev made a presentation "The impact of globalism on the effectiveness of national judicial systems."
He noted that at present, at the international level, unique systems for evaluating the effectiveness of judicial systems that take into account the economic, legal and cultural specifics have been formed and are actively used.
Candidate of Legal Sciences, Associate Professor E. A. Karakulyan made a presentation “Lessons from the history of the science of international law in the era of globalization”. He dwelled on the need to modernize international law.
L. A. Eremeishvili made a presentation “A single criterion for the sustainability of biomass and some aspects of the applicable European and international law”.
She noted that biomass is a collective concept that covers a range of materials of plant and animal origin that can replace minerals such as oil, gas and coal.
Doctor of Law, Professor A. G. Bogatyrev made a presentation on topical issues of modern international law.
He noted that there is no crisis of international law. There is a crisis of understanding and especially the application of international law. According to the speaker, national law could be a source of international law.
On June 27, the section "Actual problems of international humanitarian and criminal law" was held under the guidance of Doctor of Law, Professor AI Abdullin.
E.S. Smirnova, Ph.D. in Law, made a presentation “Internal Armed Conflict: Problems of Interaction between Politics and Law”.
She noted that the number of internal armed conflicts is constantly increasing. At the same time, their cruelty increases from year to year. In this regard, it is necessary to improve legal regulation and a unified classification of internal armed conflicts.
Postgraduate student V. S. Khachirova in her speech “Generally recognized norms and principles of international law in the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court” noted that the generally recognized norms and principles of international law are reflected in the charters of international organizations.
One such statute is the Rome Statute, which established the International Criminal Court, the main purpose of which is to end impunity for the perpetrators of the most serious international crimes of concern to the entire international community.
Post-graduate student M. S. Gavrilova in her speech “The International Legal Regime of Occupation: Current Trends in Development” drew attention to the fact that international humanitarian law is beginning to lag behind the practice of applying the occupation regime.
Candidate of Legal Sciences S. A. Knyazkin made a presentation “Problems of unification of decisions of the European Court of Human Rights in criminal and civil proceedings”.
He noted that the decisions of the European Court of Human Rights are applied in the Russian judicial system. Thus, in the Decree of June 27, 2013 No. 21 “On the application by courts of general jurisdiction of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms of November 4, 1950 and its Protocols” 3, the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation indicated that the legal positions of the European Court on human rights, which are contained in the final judgments adopted in relation to the Russian Federation, are binding on the courts.
Candidate of Law, Associate Professor V. R. Avkhadeev made a presentation “International legal regulation of control activities in the field of protecting the rights and freedoms of the indigenous peoples of the Arctic”.
He noted that the need to protect the rights and freedoms of the indigenous peoples of the Arctic is determined by climatic conditions, as well as the industrial development of resources.
Then the section "Actual Problems of International Human Rights Law" was held under the guidance of Doctor of Law, Professor S. V. Bakhin.
Candidate of Legal Sciences, Associate Professor D. E. Lyakhov in the report “The international legal component of the human right to a society free from corruption” noted that the scientific literature on international law provides for the human right to a society free from corruption.
Corruption is characterized by the following main features: conscious subordination of state interests to personal interests; secrecy of execution of decisions; existence of mutual obligations; concealment of acts of corruption.
Candidate of Legal Sciences, Associate Professor R. M. Skulakov made a presentation "The role of international law in ensuring the territorial integrity of states and the realization of human rights."
He noted that the principles of territorial integrity and the people's right to self-determination are equal in international law. However, the interests of the state are served by the principle of territorial integrity.
In this regard, it is necessary to more actively use international legal documents in the period of globalization to defend the interests of the Russian Federation in the field of ensuring the territorial integrity of states and the realization of human rights.
PhD in Law Z. G. Aliyev in his report “New trends in the field of human rights: business and human rights” noted the increasing impact of business on the implementation of human rights and considered some issues of international legal protection of children's rights, women's rights, etc.
Associate Professor B.S. Semenov made a presentation on international legal cooperation between Russia and the countries of the Asia-Pacific region, as well as on the application of international law by Russian courts of general jurisdiction, legal regulation of foreign investment, etc.
Postgraduate student D. R. Gilyazeva in her report “The Right of Indigenous Peoples to a Favorable Environment in International Law” noted that indigenous peoples are directly dependent on the natural environment. At the same time, there is no single definition of the term “indigenous people”. For indigenous peoples, the right to a favorable environment is equivalent to the right to life.
In a specially adopted statement regarding the violation of international humanitarian law in the course of armed clashes on the territory of Ukraine, the Association called on the parties to the conflict to stop armed clashes and ensure respect for human rights.
The Association listened to the report of the Doctor of Law, Professor, President of the Association A. Ya. Kapustin on the work over the past year, which was approved after an active discussion. The report of the Audit Commission was heard and unanimously approved. All participants of the Annual Meeting highly appreciated the scientific and organizational level of this event.
CHARTER International Tourism Association
"Approved"
Founders meeting
Protocol #1
Chairman of meeting
Khabarov P.S.
Meeting Secretary
Arefiev V.N.
Charter
Non-profit partnership
" INTERNATIONAL TOURISM ASSOCIATION "
2009.
1. GENERAL PROVISIONS
1.1. The non-profit partnership "INTERNATIONAL TOURISM ASSOCIATION", hereinafter referred to as the "ASSOCIATION", is a non-profit organization based on the voluntary membership of Russian and foreign citizens, individual entrepreneurs and legal entities, established to assist its members in carrying out activities aimed at achieving social, educational, scientific, managerial goals, protecting the rights, legitimate interests of citizens and organizations, resolving disputes and conflicts, providing legal assistance, as well as other activities aimed at achieving public benefits provided for by this Charter.
1.2. "ASSOCIATION" carries out its activities in accordance with the Constitution of the Russian Federation, the Civil Code of the Russian Federation, the Federal Law of the Russian Federation "On non-profit organizations" No. 7-FZ of 12.01.96 and this Charter.
1.3. "ASSOCIATION" does not have profit making as the main goal of its activity and does not distribute the profit received between the founders and (or) members. "ASSOCIATION" has the right to carry out entrepreneurial activities aimed at achieving the goals for which it was created.
1.4. The term of the "ASSOCIATION" is not limited.
1.5. Full name in Russian:
Non-commercial partnership "INTERNATIONAL TOURISM ASSOCIATION".
1.6. Abbreviated name in Russian: "INTERNATIONAL TOURISM ASSOCIATION".
1.7. Full name in English: "INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF TOURISM".
1.8. Abbreviated name in English: "IAT".
1.9. Place of establishment of the "ASSOCIATION":
RUSSIAN FEDERATION, Moscow, st. B. Yakimanka, house 24.
1.10. The location of the "ASSOCIATION" is determined by the location of the executive body.
2. LEGAL STATUS
2.1. "ASSOCIATION" acquires the rights of a legal entity from the moment of its state registration. The legal status is determined by the legislation of the Russian Federation and this Charter.
2.2. "ASSOCIATION" has separate property and funds, can acquire and exercise property and non-property rights on its own behalf, bear responsibility, be a plaintiff and defendant in court.
2.3. "ASSOCIATION" in its activities carries out the possession, use and disposal of its property in accordance with the purposes provided for by this Charter and the purpose of this property.
2.4. "ASSOCIATION" can carry out entrepreneurial activity only insofar as it serves to achieve the goals for which it was created. Such activity is the profitable production of goods and services that meet the goals of creating a non-profit organization, as well as the acquisition and sale of securities, property and non-property rights, participation in business companies and participation in limited partnerships as a contributor.
2.5. "ASSOCIATION" is responsible for its obligations with the property and funds at its disposal.
2.6. The property transferred to the "ASSOCIATION" by its members is the property of the "ASSOCIATION". Members of the "ASSOCIATION" are not liable for its obligations, and the "ASSOCIATION" is not liable for the obligations of its members.
2.7. The founders are not liable for the obligations of the "ASSOCIATION", and the "ASSOCIATION" is not liable for the obligations of its founders.
2.8. "ASSOCIATION" is not liable for the obligations of the state, just as the state is not liable for the obligations of "ASSOCIATION".
2.9. All members of the "ASSOCIATION" retain their independence and the rights of a legal entity.
2.10. "ASSOCIATION" has an independent balance sheet, is entitled to open accounts (including foreign currency) in banks in the territory of the Russian Federation and abroad in accordance with the established procedure, use loans in rubles and foreign currency, including in the form of bonded loans, on the terms and conditions determined by legislation.
2.11. "ASSOCIATION" has the right to create branches in the territory of the Russian Federation and open representative offices in accordance with the legislation of the Russian Federation. Branches and representative offices of the "ASSOCIATION" are not legal entities, are endowed with property at the expense of the "ASSOCIATION" and act on the basis of the Regulations on them approved by the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION".
2.12. The property of a branch or representative office is accounted for on a separate balance sheet and on the balance sheet of the ASSOCIATION. Branches and representative offices operate on behalf of the "ASSOCIATION". The "ASSOCIATION" is responsible for the activities of its branches and representative offices. The heads of branches and representative offices are appointed by the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION" and act on the basis of a power of attorney issued to them.
2.13. "ASSOCIATION" in the interests of achieving the goals provided for by this Charter may create, independently or jointly with other legal entities and (or) individuals on the territory of the Russian Federation and abroad, non-profit organizations with the rights of a legal entity, their branches and (or) their representative offices and other structural subdivisions that act in accordance with the Regulations on them are provided with fixed and working capital at the expense of the ASSOCIATION, have an independent balance sheet, their own accounts in banking and other credit institutions.
2.14. "ASSOCIATION" has a round seal containing its full name in Russian. "ASSOCIATION" may have stamps, forms with its name, its own emblem registered in the prescribed manner.
2.15. "ASSOCIATION" in order to implement technical, social, economic and tax policy is responsible for the safety of documents (managerial, financial and economic, etc.), stores and uses documents on personnel in the prescribed manner, ensures the transfer to state storage of documents with scientific and historical meaning.
2.16. In the course of carrying out its statutory activities, the "ASSOCIATION" may acquire and sell scientific works and other intellectual property, use the services of legal entities and (or) individuals, including foreign ones, both on the territory of the Russian Federation and abroad.
2.17. "ASSOCIATION" has the right to make settlements in cash and bills of exchange with other legal entities and (or) individuals, regardless of the form of ownership, including foreign ones.
2.18. "ASSOCIATION" has the right to carry out international telephone, telefax and other communications, access to computer databases, create its own databases and archives, use copiers, computers and other types of office equipment, as well as publishing and printing equipment and similar equipment.
3. ACTIVITIES"ASSOCIATIONS"
3.1 Purposes of activity"ASSOCIATIONS" are:
Promoting the development of tourism enterprises, the tourism services market as a whole, protecting the interests of tourism service providers;
Promoting the establishment of ties and the development of international cooperation in the field of tourism;
Protection of the collective interests of the members of the "ASSOCIATION";
Creation in Russia of a modern, highly developed, competitive tourism industry with civilized market relations;
Formation of a positive tourist image of the regions of Russia;
Promotion of the tourist product of Russia to the domestic and foreign tourist markets;
Formation of a positive tourist image of certain regions of foreign countries;
Promotion of the tourist product of foreign countries to the world tourist markets;
Facilitating the creation of favorable financial and economic conditions for members of the "ASSOCIATION" and the realization of their own creative potential;
Representing the interests of members of the "ASSOCIATION" in Russian and international governmental and non-governmental institutions and organizations;
Promoting the processes of informatization, conducting scientific and technical propaganda and implementing innovative projects of various sizes independently or in cooperation with other Russian and foreign legal entities and citizens;
Preparation and publication of information, analytical and expert materials on tourism issues for its members;
Assistance in the placement and placement of information in information networks;
Meeting the needs of members of the "ASSOCIATION" for inclusion in the global information process, assistance in the creation and creation of web pages, portals, servers and sites on the Internet;
Participation in education of the population on issues related to tourism, protection of consumer rights;
Achievement of social, charitable, cultural, educational, scientific and managerial goals, goals of protecting the health of citizens, developing physical culture, meeting the spiritual and other non-material needs of citizens, protecting the rights, legitimate interests of citizens and organizations, resolving disputes and conflicts, providing legal assistance;
3.2 In accordance with the objectives of the subject of activity"ASSOCIATIONS" is:
Identification and support of priority areas of tourism activities;
Assistance in the development of business relations between members of the "ASSOCIATION" with regional and foreign organizations;
Creation and analysis of databases of statistics of tourist flows, marketing of the tourist market;
Establishment of interregional and international relations in the field of tourism;
Organization of information, advisory and methodological assistance to members of the "ASSOCIATION";
Attraction of intellectual, financial, organizational and other resources of the members of the "ASSOCIATION" for the best realization of the professional interests of the members of the "ASSOCIATION";
Preparation of proposals for the development and implementation of a mechanism for the interaction of state authorities, local authorities with participants in the tourism business in order to develop tourism;
Representing and defending the interests of members of the "ASSOCIATION" in the authorities of various levels of the Russian Federation and foreign countries;
Legal protection of the interests of members of the "ASSOCIATION";
Assistance to state authorities and local governments in the development of federal, regional and local legal regulations, professional standards for the activities of participants in the tourism business, assistance in certification of goods and services;
Creation and financing of projects and programs aimed at the implementation of the statutory goals of the "ASSOCIATION";
Formation of a unified information database of tourist resources for members of the "ASSOCIATION";
Monitoring the quality of the provided tourist product, consumer protection activities;
Consideration and resolution of disputes in relations between members of the "ASSOCIATION", as well as in relations between members of the "ASSOCIATION" and their clients;
Carrying out a study of the state and development trends of the global information industry, the market for informatization tools and new information technologies, as well as the needs of local socio-economic structures and the region as a whole;
Assistance in the development and implementation, development and implementation of information exchange methods (e-mail, electronic news boards, electronic document management, video telephony, data exchange, holding webinars, teleconferences, creating file servers for organizing information exchange, etc.);
Satisfying the information needs of the members of the "ASSOCIATION", creating a single information space for the activities of the "ASSOCIATION" by building an information network of common access for all members of the "ASSOCIATION" to local and global information resources, creating information networks, websites, servers, portals and information channels of interest for organizations and individuals, organization and provision of information exchange services;
Combining world and Russian information flows by organizing access to the Internet and their use by the members of the ASSOCIATION, as well as representing the interests of the members of the ASSOCIATION by creating personal pages, websites and servers of the members of the ASSOCIATION on the Internet.
Attracting investments and voluntary contributions to support and develop the "ASSOCIATION" as an information, consulting, scientific, methodological and educational center, to develop its relations with public and other structures of the Russian Federation and foreign states;
Preparation, publication and distribution of information materials about the tourist potential of the regions of Russia and foreign countries, consultations, exchange of experience and joint developments with specialists in the field of informatization, computerization and other related fields;
Carrying out advertising activities in the interests of the "ASSOCIATION" and its members;
Organization and participation in promotions and events on the development of tourism: exhibitions, fairs, festivals, round tables, seminars and the like;
Organization of participation in the work of international tourism exhibitions, including the initiation of the creation of unified regional information stands that act as advertising and information offices for organizing presentations of the tourism opportunities of the regions, with the involvement of authorities and all interested enterprises and organizations;
Carrying out activities to organize the leisure of citizens, holding quizzes, contests, drawings and lotteries;
Popular science and educational activities, participation in the creation of a modern system of retraining and advanced training of personnel, the creation and implementation of training programs providing for practical training of tourism business managers;
Organization of financing of scientific research and development;
Other activities not prohibited by the current legislation of the Russian Federation in the manner prescribed by the current legislation and aimed at achieving the goals of the charter.
Certain types of activities, the list of which is determined by special federal laws, "ASSOCIATION" can be engaged only upon receipt of a special permit (license).
4. FOUNDERS
The founders of the "ASSOCIATION" are:
Egorychev Roman Stepanovich Arefiev Vladimir Nikolaevich Khabarov Pavel Sergeevich
5. MEMBERSHIP, PROCEDURE FOR ADMISSION AND WITHDRAWAL OF MEMBERS
5.1 "ASSOCIATION" is open to new members.
5.2 Members of the "ASSOCIATION" may be individuals, individual entrepreneurs and legal entities who recognize this Charter, share the goals and objectives of the "ASSOCIATION" and fulfill the provisions of this Charter.
5.3 The procedure for registration of membership in the "ASSOCIATION":
An individual, individual entrepreneur or legal entity (applicant) wishing to join the "ASSOCIATION" submits an application addressed to the PRESIDENT of the "ASSOCIATION" for admission to the membership of the Non-Commercial Partnership "INTERNATIONAL TOURISM ASSOCIATION". From the current member of the "ASSOCIATION" in the name of the PRESIDENT of the "ASSOCIATION" an application can be submitted for admission to the membership of the "ASSOCIATION" of an individual, an individual entrepreneur or a legal entity.
The PRESIDENT of the "ASSOCIATION" preliminarily considers the application and (or) petition and submits the issue of admission to membership at the next meeting of the "COUNCIL OF THE ASSOCIATION" to make a decision on admission.
5.4 The applicant after the decision of the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION" on admission to the membership of the "ASSOCIATION" is obliged to pay the entrance and membership fees within 30 days. The applicant can be considered accepted as a member of the "ASSOCIATION" after paying the entrance and annual membership fee established by the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION".
5.5 The founders of the "ASSOCIATION" are permanent members of the "ASSOCIATION", cannot be excluded from it and are released from the obligation to pay entrance, membership, registration and other targeted fees.
5.6 Members of the "ASSOCIATION" have the right to leave the "ASSOCIATION" freely at their own discretion. The withdrawal of a member from the "ASSOCIATION" is formalized by submitting a written application addressed to the PRESIDENT OF THE ASSOCIATION. Within a period of no more than three months after the submission of such an application, the "ASSOCIATION BOARD" is obliged to resolve issues related to the withdrawal of a member from the "ASSOCIATION" and no later than twelve months from the date of filing an application for withdrawal from the members of the "ASSOCIATION" to make all related calculations;
5.7 In case of gross or systematic failure to fulfill their obligations to the "ASSOCIATION", its member may be expelled from the "ASSOCIATION" by decision of the remaining members in the manner determined by this Charter.
5.8 A member of the "ASSOCIATION" who compromises the "ASSOCIATION" by his actions, does not fulfill his obligations to the "ASSOCIATION", does not comply with the requirements of this Charter, is subject to exclusion from the "ASSOCIATION" based on the decision of the "ASSOCIATION BOARD". At the same time, a member of the "ASSOCIATION", expelled from it, does not have the right to receive part of the property of the "ASSOCIATION" or its monetary equivalent, within the value of the property transferred by the member of the "ASSOCIATION", entrance annual membership, targeted and registration fees.
5.9 A member of the "ASSOCIATION BOARD" in case of withdrawal from the "ASSOCIATION" terminates his powers as a member of the "ASSOCIATION BOARD".
5.10 After resolving issues related to the voluntary withdrawal or expulsion of a member from the ASSOCIATION, at the next meeting of the ASSOCIATION BOARD, a decision is approved to withdraw the applicant from the ASSOCIATION members.
6. RIGHTS AND OBLIGATIONS OF MEMBERS"ASSOCIATIONS"
6.1 Members"ASSOCIATIONS" have the right:
Participate in the management of the affairs of the "ASSOCIATION";
Participate in the work of the General Meeting of the members of the "ASSOCIATION", make proposals to the agenda of the General Meeting of the members of the "ASSOCIATION";
Participate in all activities of the "ASSOCIATION";
Have access to all created databases of "ASSOCIATIONS";
Have access to information about the activities of the "ASSOCIATION";
By joint efforts to organize the events necessary to achieve the statutory goals of the "ASSOCIATION";
Use the resources of the "ASSOCIATION" in the amounts determined by the regulatory documents of the "ASSOCIATION" and approved by the management bodies of the "ASSOCIATION";
Contact the governing bodies of the "ASSOCIATION" on any issues related to its activities;
Transfer property, funds, intellectual property objects to the ownership of the "ASSOCIATION";
Leave the "ASSOCIATION" at its own discretion;
To receive, upon leaving the ASSOCIATION, a part of its property or a monetary equivalent within the value of the property transferred by the members of the ASSOCIATION to its ownership, with the exception of entrance, membership, registration and target fees no later than twelve months from the date of filing an application for withdrawal from the members " ASSOCIATIONS";
To receive, in the event of liquidation of the ASSOCIATION, a part of its property remaining after the satisfaction of creditors' claims, or the value of this property within the value of the property that was transferred by them to the ownership of the ASSOCIATION;
6.2 Members"ASSOCIATIONS" are obliged:
Take an active part in the activities of the "ASSOCIATION";
To assist other members of the "ASSOCIATION" in their activities corresponding to the goals prescribed in this Charter;
Comply with the provisions of this Charter, internal documents of the ASSOCIATION and decisions of the governing bodies of the ASSOCIATION;
Provide the governing bodies of the "ASSOCIATION" with the information necessary to resolve issues related to the activities of the "ASSOCIATION";
Not to disclose confidential information about the activities of the "ASSOCIATION", as well as not to provide third parties with such information received from the "ASSOCIATION";
Timely pay periodic membership (annual), targeted and registration fees;
Respect the interests of other members, strictly comply with the terms of agreements, contracts and agreements relating to the activities of the "ASSOCIATION";
To prevent cases of abuse of belonging to the "ASSOCIATION" and dishonest behavior. A member of the "ASSOCIATION" who systematically fails to perform or improperly performs his duties, or who has violated his obligations to the "ASSOCIATION", as well as hindering the normal work of the "ASSOCIATION" by his actions or inaction, may be expelled from it by decision of the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION";
Compensate for the damage caused by him (member) of the "ASSOCIATION". The damage is compensated in full on the basis of the decision taken by the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION". The amounts to be paid as compensation for the damage caused to them, and the terms of compensation are determined by the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION".
7. ORDER OF CONTROL
7.1 The supreme governing body is the General Meeting of members of the "ASSOCIATION".
7.1.1 The general meeting of the members of the "ASSOCIATION" ensures the observance of the objectives of the activities of the "ASSOCIATION", in whose interests it was created. The exclusive competence of the General Meeting of members of the "ASSOCIATION" includes:
1) Change of the Charter of "ASSOCIATION";
2) Determination of priority directions of activity of "ASSOCIATION", principles of formation and use of its property;
3) Formation of the executive and supervisory bodies of the "ASSOCIATION" and early termination of their powers;
4) Reorganization and liquidation of the non-profit partnership "INTERNATIONAL TOURISM ASSOCIATION";
5) Consideration of the reports of the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION" on the results of its activities, on the results of the audit, the correct use of the financial and material resources of the "ASSOCIATION".
7.1.2 General meetings may be regular or extraordinary. The announcement of the place and time of the holding, as well as the agenda of the General Meeting of the members of the "ASSOCIATION" is carried out no later than thirty days before the scheduled date of the meeting.
7.1.3 The next General Meeting of the "ASSOCIATION" members is convened at least once every 2 years. The general meeting of members of the "ASSOCIATION" is competent if more than half of its members are present at the said meeting. In the absence of a quorum, the date of the new General Meeting of the "ASSOCIATION" members is set. Such a date may be appointed not earlier than 30 days after the date of the failed General Meeting of the members of the "ASSOCIATION".
7.1.4 A member of the "ASSOCIATION" participates in the work of the General Meeting of members of the "ASSOCIATION" personally or through his authorized representative (representative). A member of the "ASSOCIATION" has the right to send his representative to participate in the General Meeting of the members of the "ASSOCIATION" by issuing a power of attorney to such a representative in a simple written form.
7.1.5 The decision of the General Meeting of the members of the "ASSOCIATION" is taken by a majority vote of the members present at the meeting. The decision of the general meeting on issues of exclusive competence is taken by a qualified majority of votes of ¾ of the members present.
7.1.6 An Extraordinary General Meeting of the members of the "ASSOCIATION" may be convened by the decision of the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION" adopted on the basis of an initiative coming from the PRESIDENT OF THE "ASSOCIATION", the members of the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION", the GENERAL DIRECTOR, as well as the Audit Commission (Auditor) declared at the meeting " ASSOCIATION BOARD" or an initiative coming from a group of at least 25% of the "ASSOCIATION" members.
7.1.7 If it becomes necessary to convene the General Meeting of the members of the ASSOCIATION, a group of 25% of the members of the ASSOCIATION send a written application to the PRESIDENT of the ASSOCIATION who, within 10 days, submits the issue of convening an extraordinary General Meeting of the members of the ASSOCIATION to the meeting " ASSOCIATION COUNCIL". Not later than 30 days from the date of receipt of a written application by the PRESIDENT of the "ASSOCIATION", the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION" decides to convene the General Meeting of the members of the "ASSOCIATION" and sets the date for the meeting or sends the members of the "ASSOCIATION" a reasoned opinion on the rejection of the initiative of the members of the "ASSOCIATION".
7.1.8 The GENERAL DIRECTOR of the "ASSOCIATION" is obliged to notify all members of the "ASSOCIATION" about the convening of the General Meeting of the members of the "ASSOCIATION" no later than 30 days before the scheduled date of the meeting.
7.1.9 All issues related to the convening and holding of the General Meeting of the members of the "ASSOCIATION" are within the competence of the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION".
7.1.10 Decisions of the General Meeting of the members of the "ASSOCIATION" are drawn up in minutes and signed by the PRESIDENT of the "ASSOCIATION", members of the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION" and certified by the seal of the "ASSOCIATION".
7.1.11 Members of the "ASSOCIATION" take part in the work of the General Meeting of members of the "ASSOCIATION" free of charge.
7.2 In the intervals between the General Meetings of the members of the "ASSOCIATION"The permanent collegiate management body of the "ASSOCIATION" is the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION":
7.2.1 In its work, the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION" is guided by this Charter, the decisions of the General Meeting of the members of the "ASSOCIATION", as well as its own decisions. The activity of the "ASSOCIATION COUNCIL" is built on the basis of collegial management, publicity, regular reporting to the members of the "ASSOCIATION". The competence of the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION" includes:
1) Development of the main activities of the ASSOCIATION.
2) Approval of the financial plan of the "ASSOCIATION" and making changes to it.
3) Approval of the annual report and annual balance sheet.
4) Election of the PRESIDENT of the "ASSOCIATION", VICE-PRESIDENT of the "ASSOCIATION".
5) Creation of branches and opening of representative offices of the ASSOCIATION.
6) Determining the size of entrance, annual membership, targeted and registration fees, the procedure for their payment and benefits for them.
7) Approval of the reports of the audit commission.
8) Making a decision on the appointment and early dismissal of the GENERAL DIRECTOR.
9) Issues of preparation and holding of the General Meeting of members of the "ASSOCIATION".
10) Making a decision on admission to the membership of the "ASSOCIATION" and exclusion from them. Establishment of a candidate term and category of membership for those entering the "ASSOCIATION" membership.
11) Deciding on participation in other organizations.
12) Approval of documents regulating the activities of the "ASSOCIATION" - internal documents of the "ASSOCIATION".
13) Issues of assisting other bodies of the "ASSOCIATION" in resolving issues within their competence.
14) Delegation of representatives of the "ASSOCIATION" to other organizations and meetings and recall of these Representatives.
15) Determination of the main directions of using the funds of the "ASSOCIATION" and the amount of funding for them, the procedure for accessing the resources of the "ASSOCIATION".
16) Determination of the main activities of the Executive Directorate and the adoption of reports on their implementation.
17) Delegation of part of their functions to the executive bodies.
18) Other issues, except for issues related to the exclusive competence of the General Meeting
members of the ASSOCIATION.
7.2.3 Initially, the "ASSOCIATION BOARD" consists of founders who are Permanent members of the "ASSOCIATION BOARD" and cannot be excluded from it.
7.2.4 Meetings of the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION" are competent if more than half of the members of the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION" participate in its work. Decisions are taken by a simple majority of the members of the "ASSOCIATION BOARD" participating in the meeting. In case of equality of votes of the members of the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION", a decision is made, for which the "PRESIDENT OF THE ASSOCIATION" voted at the meeting. Decisions of the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION" on issues
provided for in clause 7.2.1 p.p. 1), 2), 4), 6), 7), 10) are adopted by a qualified majority of votes of ¾ of all members of the "ASSOCIATION BOARD". Permanent members of the "ASSOCIATION COUNCIL" have the right to "veto" when voting.
7.2.5 Decisions of the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION" are drawn up in minutes and signed by the PRESIDENT of the "ASSOCIATION".
7.2.6 According to the decision of the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION", its composition can be expanded by the members of the "ASSOCIATION" who are elected at the General Meeting of the members of the "ASSOCIATION" for a period of two years. The quantitative composition of the "ASSOCIATION BOARD" is determined by the "ASSOCIATION BOARD" itself.
7.2.7 The "ASSOCIATION BOARD" meets as needed, but at least once a quarter (3 months). The order of formation, convocation, work, as well as the powers of the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION" are determined by this Charter. THE PRESIDENT OF THE "ASSOCIATION" develops and submits for approval by the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION" questions about the form and amount of remuneration to the members of the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION" for the performance of their functions.
7.2.8 The "ASSOCIATION BOARD" elects from among its permanent members the PRESIDENT of the "ASSOCIATION", who becomes the head of the "ASSOCIATION BOARD" and carries out general management of the "ASSOCIATION" in the intervals between meetings of the "ASSOCIATION BOARD" and the General Meeting of the "ASSOCIATION" members. The PRESIDENT of the "ASSOCIATION" is elected for a term of four years.
7.2.9 In case of temporary absence of the PRESIDENT of the "ASSOCIATION", his duties are performed by the VICE-PRESIDENT of the "ASSOCIATION". THE VICE-PRESIDENT OF THE "ASSOCIATION" is elected by the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION" from among its members for four years.
7.2.10 The VICE-PRESIDENT of the "ASSOCIATION" organizes the activities of the "ASSOCIATION" in certain areas and assignments, and also, on behalf of the PRESIDENT of the "ASSOCIATION", performs his duties during the absence of the PRESIDENT of the "ASSOCIATION".
7.2.11 PRESIDENT OF THE ASSOCIATION:
Carries out general management of the "ASSOCIATION", acts without a power of attorney on behalf of the "ASSOCIATION";
Represents the interests of the "ASSOCIATION" in relations with legal entities and individuals, if necessary, signs letters, appeals, contracts, etc. on behalf of the "ASSOCIATION";
Acts on behalf of the "ASSOCIATION" and has the right to make statements on behalf of the "ASSOCIATION";
Heads, organizes and manages the work of the "ASSOCIATION COUNCIL", chairs its meetings;
Presides and leads the General Meeting of members of the "ASSOCIATION";
Accepts applications, preliminary considers and submits for consideration by the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION" the issues of admission of new members and exclusion from the "ASSOCIATION";
Develops and submits for consideration by the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION" proposals on the size of entrance, membership, registration and target fees for members of the "ASSOCIATION";
Submits various proposals and initiatives for consideration to the governing bodies of the "ASSOCIATION";
Controls the current organizational and financial activities of the "ASSOCIATION", contributes to the implementation of the decisions of the General Meeting of the members of the "ASSOCIATION" and the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION";
Approves the structure, staffing, form and wages of employees of the Executive Directorate;
On behalf of the "ASSOCIATION", in accordance with clause 7.3.4, signs an employment contract - hires and dismisses the GENERAL DIRECTOR;
On behalf of the "ASSOCIATION" signs labor contracts with the members of the "ASSOCIATION BOARD" and the VICE-PRESIDENT of the "ASSOCIATION" in case they work on a permanent basis;
In the event that the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION" appoints the heads of branches and representative offices on behalf of the "ASSOCIATION", signs labor contracts with them and issues powers of attorney to them.
7.2.12 Early termination of the powers of the PRESIDENT of the "ASSOCIATION" and the VICE-PRESIDENT of the "ASSOCIATION" due to their own desire is approved by the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION" simultaneously with the subsequent election of new persons to this position in accordance with clauses 7.2.8 and 7.2.9 of this Charter.
7.3. The permanent sole executive body of the ASSOCIATION is the GENERAL DIRECTOR.
7.3.1 The GENERAL DIRECTOR organizes the implementation of the decisions of the General Meeting of the members of the ASSOCIATION, the ASSOCIATION BOARD, the Audit Commission (Auditor) and the PRESIDENT of the ASSOCIATION.
7.3.2 The GENERAL DIRECTOR heads and manages the work of the Executive Directorate, which carries out financial, economic, domestic and other daily executive activities of the ASSOCIATION.
7.3.3 The GENERAL DIRECTOR acts without a power of attorney within his powers and issues powers of attorney to perform such actions, signs documents, concludes agreements within his competence, represents the interests of the ASSOCIATION on all issues arising from the activities of the ASSOCIATION within his powers, and also resolves all issues that do not constitute the exclusive competence of the General Meeting of the members of the "ASSOCIATION", the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION", the Audit Commission and the PRESIDENT of the "ASSOCIATION", determined by this Charter;
7.3.4 The GENERAL DIRECTOR is appointed (elected) and early dismissed by the "ASSOCIATION BOARD". On behalf of the ASSOCIATION, the employment contract with the GENERAL DIRECTOR is signed by the PRESIDENT of the ASSOCIATION. The position of the GENERAL DIRECTOR cannot be combined with the positions of the PRESIDENT of the "ASSOCIATION", VICE-PRESIDENT of the "ASSOCIATION" and a member of the Audit Commission (auditor).
7.3.5 The GENERAL DIRECTOR is accountable to the General Meeting of the members of the "ASSOCIATION" and the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION".
7.3.6 The GENERAL DIRECTOR is responsible to the General Meeting of the members of the "ASSOCIATION" and the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION" for the fulfillment of their instructions and for the observance of financial, contractual and labor discipline by the employees of the Executive Directorate, as well as for the results and legality of their activities.
7.3.7 Accounting, operational and statistical accounting of the results of work and reporting of the "ASSOCIATION" are carried out in accordance with the standards in force in the Russian Federation. Responsibility for the state of accounting, timely submission of accounting and other reports of the "ASSOCIATION" to the state tax inspectorate and other government bodies, lies with the GENERAL DIRECTOR of the "ASSOCIATION", whose competence is determined by the current legislation and the Charter of the "ASSOCIATION".
7.3.8 "ASSOCIATION" in order to implement the state, social, economic and tax policy, is responsible for the safety of documents (managerial, financial and economic, personnel, etc.), ensures the transfer to state storage of documents of scientific and historical significance , in the state archives in accordance with applicable law, stores and uses documents on personnel in the prescribed manner. "ASSOCIATION" provides information about its activities to state statistics and tax authorities, founders and other persons in accordance with the legislation of the Russian Federation and this Charter.
7.3.9 The GENERAL DIRECTOR has the right to delegate his powers or part of them to his deputies.
7.3.10 GENERAL DIRECTOR:
a) performs legal actions related to the statutory activities of the "ASSOCIATION", enjoys the right to dispose of property and funds, taking into account the restrictions established by the constituent documents, concludes contracts, carries out transactions, issues orders and orders, gives instructions that are binding on all employees, according to matters within its competence;
b) develops the structure, determines the terms of remuneration, approves the duties of the employees of the Executive Directorate of the "ASSOCIATION", coordinates with the PRESIDENT of the "ASSOCIATION" the staffing table, the form and wages of the employees of the Executive Directorate;
c) takes measures to encourage and punish employees of the Executive Directorate, issues local management acts (orders, instructions, etc.), hires and dismisses employees of the Executive Directorate, concludes labor agreements (contracts);
d) concludes contracts, issues powers of attorney, issues orders and orders, gives instructions binding on all employees on issues within its competence.
e) opens bank accounts, signs financial and payment documents;
f) performs other actions within the limits of its powers, determined by this Charter and in accordance with the current legislation of the Russian Federation.
7.3.11 The duties of the GENERAL DIRECTOR include:
Logistical support of the activities of the "ASSOCIATION" within the limits of own and borrowed funds of the "ASSOCIATION";
Attraction for the implementation of the statutory activities of additional sources of financial and material resources;
Submission to the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION" of annual and periodic (upon request) reports on the receipt and expenditure of funds;
Preparation and organization of regular and extraordinary General Meetings of members of the "ASSOCIATION";
Annual report to the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION" and the General Meeting of the members of the "ASSOCIATION" on its activities;
Solving personnel issues, appointing deputies of the GENERAL DIRECTOR and their early dismissal;
Solving other issues that are not within the exclusive competence of the General Meeting of members of the ASSOCIATION, the ASSOCIATION BOARD, the Audit Commission (Auditor) and the PRESIDENT of the ASSOCIATION.
8. CONTROL OF ACTIVITIES
8.1 Control over financial and economic activities is carried out by the Audit Commission (auditor).
8.2 The Audit Commission (Auditor) is the control body of the ASSOCIATION and may consist of one to three people who control the financial and economic activities of the ASSOCIATION. The Audit Commission (Auditor) is elected from the members of the ASSOCIATION for a period of two years by the General Meeting of the members of the ASSOCIATION.
8.3 The Audit Commission (Auditor) is accountable to the General Meeting of the members of the "ASSOCIATION". The Audit Commission (Auditor) checks the activities of the "ASSOCIATION BOARD" and the Executive Directorate as necessary, but at least once a year.
8.4 The Audit Commission is managed by its Chairman (Auditor), who has the right, in agreement with the ASSOCIATION BOARD, to involve independent auditors in the audit.
8.5 Reports on the results of the audit, the correct use of the financial and material resources of the "ASSOCIATION" are submitted to the General Meeting of the members of the "ASSOCIATION".
8.6 Audit Commission (Auditor):
A) Carries out an audit of the expenditure of funds and material assets, confirmation of the reliability of the data contained in the reports and other financial documents;
B) Checks the timing and correctness of the progress of cases, work with proposals, applications and requests in the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION" and the Executive Directorate of the "ASSOCIATION";
C) Exercises control over the preparation of reports, the procedure for maintaining accounting records and the presentation of financial statements, as well as legal acts of the Russian Federation in the course of financial and economic activities;
D) Carries out control over the implementation of decisions adopted by the General Meeting of members of the "ASSOCIATION".
8.7 "ASSOCIATION" maintains accounting and statistical reporting in accordance with the procedure established by the legislation of the Russian Federation, provides information about its activities to state statistics and tax authorities, founders and other persons in accordance with the legislation of the Russian Federation and constituent documents.
8.8 The annual report on the operations of the ASSOCIATION, the report on the results of the audit and the balance sheet with the conclusion of the Audit Commission (auditor) are submitted no later than three months after the end of the financial year for approval by the ASSOCIATION BOARD.
8.9 "ASSOCIATION" and its officials bear the responsibility established by the legislation for reliability of the data contained in the annual report and balance sheet.
9. PROPERTY
9.1. The property of the "ASSOCIATION" is created at the expense of:
9.1.2 Entrance, annual membership, targeted and registration fees of members of the "ASSOCIATION", voluntary property and monetary contributions, donations from legal entities and individuals, including foreign ones;
9.1.3 Income from the sale of goods, works, services;
9.1.4 Income from operations with securities and other financial instruments;
9.1.5 Business income;
9.1.6 Bank loans and loans from other creditors;
9.1.7 Income received from the use of the ASSOCIATION's property, including intellectual property;
9.1.8 Free work of volunteers;
9.1.9 Other sources that do not contradict the current legislation.
9.2. When joining the "ASSOCIATION", a candidate member of the "ASSOCIATION" (applicant) pays an entrance fee and an initial membership fee in the amount determined by the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION". The second and subsequent annual membership fees are paid by each member of the "ASSOCIATION" during the first six calendar months of the current year.
9.3. Contributions may be paid in cash, securities, other property and intellectual property. The value of the contributed property and intellectual property is estimated by agreement between the member of the "ASSOCIATION" (applicant) and the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION" in rubles or foreign currency. Members of the "ASSOCIATION" lose the right to dispose of the property transferred as a contribution.
9.4. The size of the entrance and annual membership fees for members of the "ASSOCIATION", as well as changes related to the amount, term and forms of contributions, are established by the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION".
9.5. Entrance, annual membership and registration fees are used to maintain the governing bodies and ensure the activities provided for by this Charter.
9.6. Earmarked contributions are intended to finance specific activities and programs. The term, amount and form of targeted contributions are established by the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION".
9.7. The "ASSOCIATION" uses the property received from the members of the "ASSOCIATION" and (or) leases the property for the organization and implementation of statutory activities.
9.8. "ASSOCIATION" has the right to attract, in accordance with the procedure established by the legislation of the Russian Federation, additional financial resources, including foreign exchange resources and property from individuals and legal entities, including foreign ones.
9.9. The "ASSOCIATION" may own buildings, structures, equipment, inventory, cash in rubles and foreign currency, securities, other property, the value of which is reflected in the balance sheet of the "ASSOCIATION".
9.10. "ASSOCIATION" may own or otherwise have land plots and other property not prohibited by law.
9.11 "ASSOCIATION" independently carries out the activities provided for by the Charter and manages the income from this activity.
9.12 Income cannot be distributed among the members of the "ASSOCIATION".
9.13 The founders of the "ASSOCIATION" are exempt from paying entrance, annual membership, registration and other targeted fees.
9.14 Funds of the "ASSOCIATION" are spent to achieve the goals and fulfill the tasks provided for by this Charter.
10. PROCEDURE FOR REORGANIZATION AND LIQUIDATION
10.1. The reorganization of the "ASSOCIATION" is carried out in the manner prescribed by the current legislation of the Russian Federation. The reorganization can be carried out in the form of a merger, accession, separation, separation and transformation.
10.2. The reorganization entails the transfer of the rights and obligations of the "ASSOCIATION" to its successors. The decision on the transformation of the "ASSOCIATION" is taken by the General Meeting of the members of the "ASSOCIATION".
10.3. The liquidation of the "ASSOCIATION" can be carried out:
By decision of the General Meeting of members of the "ASSOCIATION";
Based on a court decision;
In other cases provided by the current legislation.
10.4. Liquidation takes place by a liquidation commission appointed by the General Meeting of the ASSOCIATION members, and in case of liquidation by an arbitration or court decision - by a liquidation commission appointed by these bodies.
10.5. Since the appointment of the liquidation commission, the powers to manage the affairs of the "ASSOCIATION" are transferred to it. The liquidation commission evaluates the ASSOCIATION's property, identifies its creditors and debtors and settles accounts with them, draws up a liquidation balance sheet and submits it to the General Meeting of the ASSOCIATION members.
10.6. The liquidation commission places in the press a publication on the liquidation of the "ASSOCIATION", the procedure and deadline for filing claims by its creditors.
10.7. At the end of the term for the presentation of claims by creditors, the liquidation commission draws up an interim liquidation balance sheet. The liquidation interim balance sheet is approved by the General Meeting of the members of the "ASSOCIATION", which made a decision on its liquidation.
10.8. After completion of settlements with creditors, the liquidation commission draws up a liquidation balance sheet, which is approved by the General Meeting of members of the "ASSOCIATION" or the body that made the decision to liquidate.
10.9. The property remaining after satisfaction of creditors' claims or its value is subject to distribution among the members of the "ASSOCIATION" in proportion to the size of their property contribution. The rest of the property, the value of which exceeds the amount of property contributions of the ASSOCIATION members, is directed to the purposes for which the ASSOCIATION was created, (or) to charitable purposes.
10.10. "ASSOCIATION" is considered to have ceased to exist from the moment the relevant entry is made in the Unified State Register of Legal Entities.
10.11. When the ASSOCIATION is reorganized or terminated, all documents (management, financial and economic, personnel, etc.) are transferred in accordance with the established rules to its successor. In the absence of an assignee, documents of permanent storage of scientific and historical significance are transferred to the state archives for storage. Documents on personnel (orders, personal files, record cards, personal accounts, etc.) are transferred for storage to the archive, on the territory of which the "ASSOCIATION" is located. The transfer and ordering of documents is carried out by the forces and at the expense of the "ASSOCIATION" in accordance with the requirements of archival authorities.
10.12. The Liquidation Commission bears property liability for the damage caused by it to the ASSOCIATION, its members and third parties in accordance with the legislation of the Russian Federation.
11. DISPUTES RESOLUTION
All disputes on the affairs of the "ASSOCIATION" between its members, disputes of the "ASSOCIATION" with individuals and legal entities are resolved by the "BOARD OF THE ASSOCIATION" or the General Meeting of the members of the "ASSOCIATION", if both disputing parties agree to this, or if an agreement is not reached, in court . The decisions of the court are final and binding on the disputing parties.
12. PROCEDURE FOR THE ENTRY OF THE CHARTER INTO FORCE AND ITS AMENDMENT
12.1. The Charter comes into force from the moment of the state registration of the "ASSOCIATION".
12.2. Changes to this Charter are made by decision of the General Meeting of members of the "ASSOCIATION" with subsequent state re-registration of the Charter.